Software Stack Investing

Investing analysis of the software companies that power next generation digital businesses

Page 2 of 15

Confluent (CFLT) Q1 2023 Earnings Review

Following their Q1 earnings report on May 3rd, Confluent stock jumped by 16%. Since then, CFLT has continued appreciating, recently passing their previous high for 2023. While the report itself was pretty good (but not outstanding), the market appears to be anticipating more growth to come. Perceived AI tailwinds are likely at play. In order to capitalize on the potential advantages from advanced insights and new proprietary AI models, enterprises need access to all their data in one place. It should be filtered, consistent and recent. As the leading independent provider of data streaming, and soon stream processing capabilities, Confluent is well positioned to address this demand.

Fortunately, Confluent doesn’t have to convince most enterprises of the value of real-time data streaming. Over 75% of the Fortune 500 already use Apache Kafka at some level to accomplish this. Confluent’s task is to demonstrate that their data streaming platform, which offers many enhanced capabilities over self-managed open source Kafka, is worth the incremental cost. While this may have been a more difficult sell in the corporate data center, Confluent Cloud provides enterprises with a managed solution on their hyperscaler of choice, eliminating the need to maintain a large team of operations engineers with Kafka expertise.

Additionally, stream processing tools allow data engineers to filter, transform and aggregate data in flight, front-loading processing before it arrives at its destination. The most popular open source solution for stream processing is Apache Flink. With their acquisition of Immerok in January, Confluent is now integrating a managed Flink stream processing toolset into their core Cloud platform. Management expects that revenue from stream processing could eventually match that of core data streaming, effectively doubling their TAM.

While their Q1 results continued to reflect the pressure of elongated deal cycles and enhanced scrutiny, Confluent managed to deliver subscription revenue growth over 40% y/y. For the remainder of 2023, they maintained revenue targets at conservative levels. Profitability measures dipped in Q1 due to a couple of one-time charges, but are tracking towards break-even operating margin in Q4. That will represent another 2000 bps of annual improvement. Long term, the Confluent management team sees FCF margin reaching 25%.

Revenue growth is primarily being driven by expansion of Confluent’s largest customers, with continued increases in $1M+ commitments and even anecdotal references to $5M-$10M of annual spend. Confluent’s NRR rate remains above 130% overall, with NRR for just Cloud well above that. Confluent needs to keep the new customer pipeline flowing, as focus has shifted to Kafka migrations and workload expansions within existing customers. Confluent’s revenue target for this year represents about 1% of their calculated $100B addressable market, leaving plenty of room for future expansion.

Continue reading

Cloudflare (NET) Q1 2023 Earnings Review

After setting an optimistic target for full year 2023 revenue growth in early February, Cloudflare management was forced to reset guidance lower after sales cycles unexpectedly elongated in March. While this can be attributed to exogenous effects like banking turmoil and macro conditions, investors are left guessing whether the Q1 results were a one-time speed bump or a precursor to further deceleration in growth.

This dilemma would be difficult to reconcile had we been left with just the Q1 report. That earnings call conflated a few contributors to the underperformance, including longer customer sales cycles and a restructuring of the GTM team. Fortunately, Cloudflare leadership scheduled an Investor Day a week later, which provided a much clearer picture of the performance drivers and a better understanding of Cloudflare’s plan to address these challenges.

Stepping back, Cloudflare’s history and future growth are grounded in disruption. An investment in Cloudflare represents a bet that their architecture choices and platform strategy will allow them to penetrate new markets through lower cost, better performance and a more robust feature set. They have applied these architectural advantages to pursue an enormous addressable market, representing some of the fastest growing segments of software and security infrastructure.

Cloudflare’s elevated valuation relative to peers hinges on the market’s assumption that Cloudflare will continue to innovate and increase enterprise adoption of their newer product categories like Zero Trust, network services and a distributed developer platform. Rapid expansion in these areas will offset the gradual decay of growth rates in their traditional product offerings like DDOS, application security and CDN.

Continue reading

Q1 2023 Hyperscaler Earnings Review

Coming out of 2022, the catchphrase of the Q4 earnings reports from the hyperscalers was “customer workload optimization”. This referred to the process by enterprise customers of scrubbing their cloud infrastructure bills for savings. This exercise introduced a headwind to revenue growth, offsetting the positive impact of new customer cloud migration projects and digital transformation efforts. This effect drove deceleration in Q4 revenue growth rates for AWS, Microsoft Azure and GCP.

To further dampen sentiment, all three hyperscalers reported continued weakness in Q1 and avoided direct predictions as to when optimization might end. Given that they only provide guidance one quarter forward, management could remain vague around the expected revenue trajectory for the full year 2023.

While discouraging, the hyperscalers largely delivered results that were “better than feared”. Microsoft stock even rallied 8% the day after earnings. AMZN initially surged on an overall Q1 beat, but pulled back on commentary reflecting ongoing revenue growth pressure in AWS expected for Q2. Hyperscaler results also dragged notable software infrastructure companies along with them, with stocks like DDOG, MDB and SNOW surging and then dropping as each hyperscaler reported.

Investors did receive some hints in the Q1 report commentary about the potential trajectory of optimization going forward. The Microsoft team asserted that optimization impact will end eventually, while Amazon reiterated their long-term view that AWS has an enormous market to pursue. When the impact of optimization efforts does taper off, hyperscaler revenue growth can revert to being driven by new customer workloads from cloud migration and digital transformation projects.

Continue reading

Looping Back on Confluent (CFLT)

Following disappointing results from the hyperscalers, Confluent was one of the first independent software infrastructure providers to report Q4 earnings on January 30th. Further complicating the picture, they preceded that report with an announcement of an 8% staff reduction on January 26th. That filing included top-level Q4 results. This flurry of news overshadowed two key points from the reports that subsequently became clear.

First, Confluent largely maintained their revenue growth target for full year 2023 that had been previously set in Q3. Initially, the market seemed to be anticipating the standard q/q raise. However, subsequent earnings reports from other software infrastructure providers made it clear that just maintaining guidance represented a positive signal, as several companies made fairly significant downward revisions to their full year revenue target from either what analysts had modeled or the company’s own guidance from the prior quarter. Among peers, Confluent was one of few companies that kept the target about the same.

Second, the driver of the layoff was a desire to pull in profitability targets by a year. Because force reductions can be organizationally disruptive and sometimes a signal of worsening demand, the layoff was initially interpreted negatively. The full Q4 report provided sufficient evidence that demand was softening, but not falling off a cliff, as new customer activity was strong.

The upside to the staff reduction is a significant decrease in expenses. Confluent’s revised operating margin target for end of year 2023 is now Non-GAAP break-even. If achieved, Confluent will have improved their operating margin by 2000 bps (20%) for two years in a row. They have telegraphed that FCF margins will follow a similar path.

These two factors, along with other positive signals in the report and earnings call, make Confluent’s results look more favorable relative to peers. When compared to subsequent reports from most other software providers, Confluent is forecasting less revenue growth deceleration and a marked improvement in operating margin.

This momentum may well provide investors with a favorable set-up going into 2024. Looking to next year, we could have a situation in which Confluent is growing at 30%+ revenue with positive operating margin. The stock appears fairly valued now, implying that further price appreciation could increase proportionally to revenue growth.

Continue reading

MongoDB (MDB) Q4 FY2023 Earnings Review

With MongoDB’s Q4 earnings report following most peers in the software infrastructure space, investors were bracing for decelerating revenue growth and a conservative guide for the upcoming year. MongoDB delivered just that. While Q4 notched a nice beat on revenue with growth of 36% annually, the preliminary guide for FY2024 came in at just 16% growth, almost 10% below analyst estimates.

That level of deceleration would normally torpedo a stock, but MDB closed the following day lower by about 8%. In subsequent weeks, the stock recovered that drop and recently closed above its pre-earnings price. Granted, most software stocks benefited from a favorable boost over the last week. This price action implies that the market is anticipating a recovery for the software sector and that preliminary revenue guidance may be conservative.

While sales growth is struggling, MongoDB is demonstrating a rapid improvement in profitability. Q4 was their highest level of Non-GAAP operating margin to date, passing 10% for the first time. This coincided with a 400 bps improvement in gross margin and record free cash flow. Looking forward, preliminary estimates for EPS surpassed analyst targets. The full year FY2024 operating margin target is starting at 5%, slightly higher than what was delivered in all of FY2023. I expect this to increase as the year progresses, just as it did in 2022.

Similar to peers, MongoDB’s explanation for subdued revenue growth is slower spend expansion by existing customers. In times of economic stress, MongoDB is hit by a double whammy. As a consumption business, if their customers experience a slowdown in digital activity, then Atlas usage decreases. Additionally, customers will delay workload migration projects, as they try to manage costs. These factors combined to force MongoDB leadership to set a low revenue growth target for FY2024, expecting that these headwinds will continue.

Continue reading

Snowflake (SNOW) Q4 FY2023 Earnings Review

Leading up to Snowflake’s Q4 FY2023 earnings report, investors felt insulated from the risk of a low revenue guide for the full year. This concern had been abated in the Q3 report, as management blunted a reduced Q4 revenue guide with a preliminary estimate that FY2024 would deliver product revenue growth of 47%. During the Q3 earnings call, this had the immediate effect of propping up the lagging after-hours stock price.

When management lowered their actual guidance in the Q4 report on March 1st to reflect product revenue growth of 40% y/y, investors were disappointed. Expectations for higher growth had already been set. Stepping back though, without the pre-announcement, a 40% guide may have been fine. Combined with an adjusted FCF margin target for the year of 25% puts Snowflake in the rare position of maintaining performance above the Rule of 60 in a tough spending environment. That target would deliver about $700M in free cash flow for this year.

Compared to other software infrastructure peers, Snowflake enjoys one of the highest valuations. Its market cap is about $44B with a trailing P/S ratio of 21. With optimistic revenue estimates, this ratio comes down quickly. At analysts’ revised revenue target for FY2024 (current calendar year), the forward P/S ratio is 15.5. Looking out two years with the FY2025 revenue estimate for $4.024B in revenue, the forward P/S approaches 11. Currently, analysts are projecting a revenue growth rate of 38.9% for FY2025, which is just a tick below the revised projection for FY2024 (this year) for 40.2% revenue growth.

That linearity forms the crux of the Snowflake investment thesis. If the company can continue expanding into their seemingly uncapped TAM at a durable revenue growth rate around 40%, then the opportunity for upside is reasonable. Combined with an adjusted FCF margin of 25% (or more), a premium valuation multiple appears fair. The price to FCF multiple for FY2024 lands at about 63 – not outlandish considering that Snowflake more than doubled FCF over the past year.

Continue reading

Datadog (DDOG) Q4 2022 Earnings Review

After enjoying several years of hypergrowth, Datadog’s revenue outlook for this year reflects a substantial slowdown. The challenge for investors is to discern whether annual growth in the mid-20% range is the new norm for Datadog or reflective of headwinds from the broader pullback in IT spend. Similar to the discussion around hyperscaler growth trajectories, enterprise IT teams are using this period of macro pressure to optimize their software infrastructure spend.

This optimization is a natural outcome of the rush to push through cloud migrations and feature releases during Covid with little oversight to spending levels. With IT budgets contracting, the opposite motion is taking hold, magnified by a concentrated effort to address accumulated optimization debt. After ignoring bloat for two years, enterprise IT teams are scrambling to lower costs. For the hyperscalers, this is a straightforward exercise. A plethora of options and flexibility make it very easy to reduce server instance sizing, commit to longer usage terms and even turn off services that are underutilized. The same advantages of cloud elasticity that drove rapid growth during boom times can apply a similarly acute impact on spend if reduction is the goal.

Opportunities to optimize spend on Datadog exist as well – not the same mechanics as with the hyperscalers, but familiar patterns. Customers can remove Datadog licenses from some hosts (APM, Infrastructure), shorten log retention periods (Log Management) or even limit the number of test runs (RUM, Synthetics, Continuous Testing). Further, as customers introduce new cloud workloads, they might forgo monitoring or apply limited observability coverage to their tiers. If customers delay a digital transformation project, that would impact Datadog spending growth as well.

As with the hyperscalers, these optimization efforts are creating a headwind to Datadog’s normal spend expansion. While customers are adopting multiple Datadog products at the same rate, they are ramping up utilization more slowly, or even optimizing down, on existing workloads. By not expanding spend as infrastructure tiers go through this one-time capacity adjustment, Datadog’s sequential revenue growth is being compressed.

Continue reading

Cloudflare (NET) Q4 2022 Earnings Review

Cloudflare’s Q4 FY2022 earnings report was much anticipated by the market. Like other software infrastructure companies with their fiscal Q4 aligned to the calendar year, investors received their first firm view of guidance for not just the current quarter, but also the full year of 2023. Given trends that I discussed in a prior post, results from the hyperscalers pointed to further deceleration in cloud utilization as a consequence of workload “optimization” by customers. As the hyperscalers generally only project results a quarter forward, investors lack a clear signal as to when optimization headwinds might abate. A few software companies reported in the interim, providing some support for a view that software infrastructure demand might level out over the full year.

Additionally, as part of their Q3 2022 earnings report, Cloudflare leadership recognized the milestone of a $1B revenue run rate with a new ambitious growth target. They expect to reach a $5B revenue run rate within 5 years – specifically meaning that revenue in Q3 2027 would be $1.25B. This implies a revenue CAGR of 38% for the next 5 years. With the demand environment deteriorating further since the Q3 report in early November, investors were left to wonder if Cloudflare would have to revise this target coming into 2023. Close followers of the company would have noticed that they quietly reiterated the goal in a press release announcing a leadership hire in January.

Nonetheless, coming into the Q4 report analysts were looking for $1.312B in revenue for FY2023, representing growth of 34.6% over their FY2022 estimate. Surprisingly, Cloudflare issued guidance for revenue of $1.330B – $1.342B, representing growth of 37.0% at the midpoint above the actual FY2022 revenue. In this environment, where most software companies are just meeting or even lowering the forward year revenue estimate, Cloudflare’s initial guide a couple points above expectations seemed detached from reality. Assuming they follow a standard, but subdued beat/raise cadence as the year progresses, they might even end 2023 with revenue growth around 40%. This would outpace most peers in the software and security space.

This full year guide left analysts perplexed. Some just don’t believe it, assuming Cloudflare management is setting themselves up for failure. Guggenheim even reiterated their Sell rating, after having downgraded the stock in January. They raised their price target slightly from $36 to $43, and expressed that “2023 revenue guidance implies an unlikely material increase in new business signings from that seen in 2022.” In their view, Cloudflare’s execution risk is much higher with this guide.

Continue reading

Q4 2022 Hyperscaler Earnings Review

Over the last two weeks, we received earnings results from the three hyperscalers – AWS, Google Cloud Platform and Microsoft Azure. Additionally, several software companies reported, providing another view of trends in software infrastructure and developer tooling. If that wasn’t enough, various economic reports and a Fed meeting were mixed in. I won’t cover the macro developments, beyond commenting on how they influenced market performance during the period and exacerbated the market’s reaction.

Overall, we received mixed signals. On one hand, the hyperscalers exhibited a deceleration in revenue growth, as customers used this period to “optimize” cloud usage and stretch out projects. On the other hand, several software companies reported revenue with less deceleration and surprisingly linear growth projections looking forward. A couple of explanations might be drawn from this.

First, while software infrastructure company sales are correlated to usage of cloud resources, certain companies may be more insulated from the effects of resource optimization. In some cases, pricing models by host or service have less elasticity than options available for hyperscaler optimization, like server downsizing, reserved instances and cold storage. Additionally, a few software infrastructure companies have been experiencing ongoing optimization over a longer period, going back to early 2022.

Second, the hyperscalers issue limited forward projections. They generally report revenue performance for just the prior quarter and sprinkle in a little verbal commentary about the current quarter. None of them project growth for the full year, which is particularly important now as most software companies are providing their preliminary full year 2023 guidance.

This leaves investors with a confounding dilemma. They could project the hyperscaler Q1 growth commentary reflecting further deceleration downward through all of 2023. Or, they could follow the lead of the software company full year estimates and factor in some re-acceleration going into the second half of the year. A deeper look into the mechanics of workload optimization may provide insight into this apparent divergence.

Continue reading

ServiceNow (NOW) – The Platform for Digital Business

ServiceNow has evolved over the last ten years from a specialized ITSM provider to a full-featured low code platform with ready-made solutions for a number of common enterprise business functions.  If you were to believe the often hyperbolic CEO, ServiceNow will become the only software platform needed by enterprises to address digital transformation.  While their product expansion has been impressive, I think their scope will land somewhere in between.

ServiceNow (NOW) is a company that I have followed for years and have owned in the past. While we tend to see large software services vendors slow down revenue growth as they pass $1B in sales, ServiceNow is exhibiting staying power by executing product expansion across multiple, adjacent service categories and then cross-selling them into the largest enterprises. This motion drives enormous spend elasticity, with nearly 100 customers exceeding $10M in ACV.

The company started in 2004 with IT Service Management, basically delivering a better software solution for the enterprise IT Helpdesk.  This naturally expanded into other IT services, like asset management, operations management, portfolio management, governance and compliance and more recently security operations.  At their core, all of these business processes are organized around “workflows”, which represent a series of steps taken by the user, a specific data model to store the state of their interactions and logic to control the flow and enforce business rules.  The original model mirrored a “ticketing” system. Since then, workflows have evolved into full-fledged applications.  

Continue reading
« Older posts Newer posts »